B.C. Supreme Court in Chilliwack

Drug charges stayed in case ‘burdened’ with difficulties

Arsheep Dhaliwal of Abbotsford began trial last July

An Abbotsford man who was on trial for drug possession has had his charges stayed after a B.C. Supreme Court judge ruled that evidence in the case was not presented in a timely or accurate manner.

Arshdeep Dhaliwal began his trial last summer on two charges of possession for the purpose of trafficking – one charge for heroin, the other for cocaine – from Feb. 4, 2015.

The trial began July 25, 2017, continued on July 28 and did not resume again until Dec. 4 and 5.

The Crown’s case included evidence of police surveillance of two properties in Abbotsford, including an apartment building on Holland Avenue.

In a written ruling, Justice George Macintosh said the pretrial disclosure about that property was “extremely limited,” stating only that Dhaliwal was seen entering a unit in the building.

In the first week of the trial, Crown counsel told the court that the manager of the apartment building had given police a key job, allowing them to enter the building and place a non-recording camera under the door of a common room to observe the hall adjacent to that unit.

Macintosh said that no particulars about this situation were given during the trial dates in July, including when the surveillance occurred, who conducted it, and when and how often Dhaliwal was seen there.

When the trial resumed in December, Crown counsel indicated that he had spoken with an APD officer who said that police had not had specific permission to place the camera in the Holland Avenue building for their investigation into Dhaliwal.

“Instead, the police had a ‘history’ with that building manager, whereby he had given the police a key fob, and perhaps a key, in an earlier investigation, and the police were proceeding on the basis they had open-ended and limitless access to the building for any police work from that time forward,” Macintosh wrote.

Other new information presented at the trial in December included that there were security cameras in the building. Police had accessed those in one or two other investigations, and may have done so in their investigation into Dhaliwal.

But Crown said he had been unable to receive a clear answer on that matter.

Macintosh referred to these discrepancies as “difficulties which appear to have burdened the case from the beginning.”

He said he believed that the Crown had been candid with the court in relaying information as he received it from police.

“Regrettably, it does not appear that he has received from the police all the information he should have received when he should have received it,” the judge stated.

Macintosh said the problems in the case prevented Dhaliwal from being able to properly defend himself, and he ruled that the charges should be stayed.

“An accused need to know the whole of the case against him before the lawyer starts the first cross-examination, not halfway through a trial,” he wrote, adding that this was one of the “clearest of cases” that necessitated a stay.

The judge’s ruling was made Dec. 6 in B.C. Supreme Court in Chilliwack but was not posted online until this week.

Just Posted

VIDEO: Man killed in shooting at Abbotsford bank

Police believe incident on Thursday night to be targeted

Online fundraiser to cover funeral costs of motorcyclist killed in collision

Larry Nizio, 37, died after crash with pickup truck Oct. 12 in Abbotsford

Silverdale development will move forward once district staff satisfied that all conditions met

Mission council approves zoning, OCP changes, but adds restrictive covenant

Mission council denies motion that would delay new construction in Silverdale

Coun. Danny Plecas’ suggestion receive little support

T-Rex warns drivers to slow down in school zones, or be eaten

Principal and parents at Silverdale Elementary in Mission are urging drivers to obey speed limits

Fashion Fridays: You can never have enough shoes

Kim XO, lets you know the best online shopping tips during Fashion Fridays on the Black Press Media Network

Feds dead set against ‘ridiculous’ quotas to replace steel, aluminum tariffs

Donald Trump imposed the so-called Section 232 tariffs — 25 per cent on steel and 10 per cent on aluminum — back in June on national security grounds.

Campus brawl leads to charge against B.C. football player

Takudzwa Timothy Brandon Gandire, a 21-year-old defensive back from Vancouver, is charged with assault causing bodily harm.

Stadium vendor seen in pizza spitting video pleads guilty

The 21-year-old’s sentencing is Nov. 15. His lawyer has said he understood what he did was wrong and was remorseful.

5 to start your day

Man killed in shooting at Abbotsford bank, ex-Surrey cop to appear in court after Creep Catchers sting and more

Jury finds Calgary couple guilty in 2013 death of toddler son

Jeromie and Jennifer Clark were found guilty of criminal negligence causing death

Fed report to show $19-billion deficit in 2017-18

The deficit is slightly smaller than Finance Minister Bill Morneau’s prediction of $19.4 billion in last winter’s budget

Vancouver Island homeowners buy more earthquake insurance than the rest of B.C.

Insurance Bureau of Canada says that’s because the perception of risk is greater on the Island

Jets score 3 late goals to beat Canucks 4-1

Winnipeg ends three-game Vancouver win streak

Most Read