A sentencing hearing was held April 12 for Andrew Mullaly for the ongoing sexual abuse of a girl who was between the ages of 11 and 16. (Facebook)

Judge questions joint submission for Chilliwack man who sexually assaulted girl

Crown, defence ordered to find case law to back up one-year sentencing for Andrew Mullaly

The provincial court judge tasked with sentencing a Chilliwack man who sexually and mentally abused a young girl over five years is questioning the joint submission from Crown and defence.

In what seemed to some in attendance like a rushed sentencing hearing late on a Friday, Crown counsel Grant Lindsey and defence lawyer Darrel Schultz told Judge Andrea Ormiston that one year in jail was a suitable sentence for Andrew Mullaly.

Mullaly was charged with sexual assault, extortion and possession of child pornography for ongoing abuse of a girl from the time she was 11 until 16. The multi-year abuse and humiliation began with his form of “punishment” where she was forced to strip naked for him. That expanded to him filming her in the shower at least once, and led to repeated instances of sexual touching and sexual assault.

• READ MORE: Young girl sexually, mentally tormented for five years by Chilliwack man

During the brief hearing on April 12, Lindsey read parts of a victim impact statement from the girl, in which she said she felt “used, manipulated, hopeless, ashamed.”

Given the late hour that day, and the seriousness of the case, Ormiston told the lawyers she would not accede to the joint submission without giving the matter further thought. The case was back in court on April 23 where Ormiston still did not agree to the joint submission, but rather ordered the two lawyers to come back with case law backing up the legitimacy of a one-year jail term for this particular crime.

In Canadian law, judges are not bound by joint submissions, however, the courts are generally reluctant to divert from what is proposed by both Crown or defence assuming there is case law showing similar sentences for similar crimes.

According to the Ministry of Justice’s Crown counsel policy manual, Crown should agree to present a joint submission “only where satisfied that a joint submission is appropriate in the public interest and, in particular, will not bring the administration of justice into disrepute.”

Crown also should present the legal basis in court so that the decision is “readily understood by the court and members of the public.”

There are cases where judges have decided the joint submission is inappropriate. In November of last year, Crown and defence issued a joint submission of five years in jail for Surrey drug dealer Jagdeep Singh Cheema who pleaded guilty to drug trafficking and firearms offences.

But B.C. Supreme Court Justice Catherine Murray said the drug-related violence in Surrey was “out of control,” that Cheema was willing and ready to participate in gun warfare, and she was unsatisfied with the sentence. Justice Murray gave Cheema eight years instead.

• READ MORE: Judge says Surrey drug dealer was ready for ‘gun warfare’

Mullaly’s next scheduled court date is May 13. Judge Ormiston will either hear from Crown and defence on a date prior to that to pass sentence on May 13, or on May 13 she will hear from the lawyers and sentencing will likely be put over to another date.

• RELATED: Former Chilliwack sports coach charged with sexually assaulting youth


@PeeJayAitch
paul.henderson@theprogress.com

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Comments are closed

Just Posted

UPDATE: One woman taken away on stretcher after three-vehicle collision at Maclure and Clearbrook Road intersection

Abbotsford emergency crews are on scene but traffic is slow eastbound on Maclure

VIDEO: Looking back at the 1968 Abbotsford International Airshow

Footage from the past show available to view online

Missing man last seen in Chilliwack Sept. 7

Friends concerned for well-being of 44-year-old Jean Pierre Baril

Abbotsford hospital has ‘extraordinary’ challenges, says health minister as ER construction nears

Construction to begin this fall on expanded emergency department at Abbotsford Regional Hospital

VIDEO: Vancouver Island mayor details emergency response after fatal bus crash

Sharie Minions says she is ‘appalled’ by condition of road where bus crashed

B.C. VIEWS: Cutting wood waste produces some bleeding

Value-added industry slowly grows as big sawmills close

Pedestrian struck and killed by vehicle in Surrey

Investigators were asking anyone who witnessed the incident to come forward

Fewer trees, higher costs blamed for devastating downturn in B.C. forestry

Some say the high cost of logs is the major cause of the industry’s decline in B.C.

Federal food safety watchdog says batch of baby formula recalled

The agency says it’s conducting a food safety investigation

Vancouver’s Tristan Connelly shocks the UFC world

Late replacement upsets big favourite Pereira, main event sees Gaethje stop Cerrone in round one

UVic president offers condolences after two students killed in bus crash

‘We also grieve with those closest to these members of our campus community,’ Cassels says

Coming Home: B.C. fire chief and disaster dog return from hurricane-ravaged Bahamas

The pair spent roughly one week on Great Abaco Island assisting in relief efforts

Newcomer Ferland lines up with sniper Pettersson as Vancouver Canucks camp opens

Ferland provides more depth and a scoring threat up front, Pettersson says

Most Read