Workers’ cancer cluster claim denied by court

The Court of Appeal is just the latest body to rule on whether or not the women’s employment at the hospital led to the cancer

The B.C. Court of Appeal has upheld a previous court ruling finding no proof for the claim that working at Mission Memorial Hospital’s lab caused breast cancer in former workers.

In the December ruling, the Court of Appeal set aside a previous Workers Compensation Appeal Tribunal decision that had found in favour of Patricia Schmidt, Katrina Hammer and Anne MacFarlane, and agreed with a 2013 Supreme Court decision.

Six lab technicians at the hospital contracted breast cancer between 1970 and 2004 in what was deemed a “cancer cluster.”

The Court of Appeal is just the latest body to rule on whether or not the women’s employment at the hospital led to the cancer.

After the Workers Compensation Board ruled against the women, a Workers’ Compensation Administrative Tribunal (WCAT) disagreed and found in favour of the former MMH employees in 2011.

But the Fraser Health Authority appealed and in 2013, that decision was quashed.

In December, with the case back in court, three of five court of appeal justices again found that the WCAT ruling was “patently unreasonable” and that beyond “an unexplained statistical anomaly” there was no evidence that employment in the lab caused the women to develop breast cancer.

“The suggestion that the cancer was caused by her employment conditions does not rise above speculation,” wrote Justice Richard Goepel.

He agreed with the Supreme Court justice who noted that “a higher-than-expected rate of cancer in a workplace cannot alone provide evidence that the cancer was caused by occupational factors” given a report stating clusters of cancer in a workplace are statistically certain to arise in various places and times.

Two justices dissented, noting that while a court of law would favour a “more technical reading” of expert reports, the WCAT’s decision was not unreasonable and thus should not be before the courts.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Provincial COVID-19 data can now be used for B.C. to prepare for a second wave

In the past week, B.C. has seen a slight spike in daily test-positive case counts

Child falls down Bridal Veil Falls near Chilliwack, crews on scene

An 11-year-old boy fell over the falls about 25 to 30 feet and has suffered a head injury

Once-in-a-lifetime comet photographed soaring over Abbotsford

Photographer Randy Small captures Comet NEOWISE in early-morning sky

Man shot dead in east Abbotsford suburbs

Integrated Homicide Investigative Team called to investigate

Popular retired UFV therapy dog passes away

Mac the Therapy Dog consoled countless students and staff, as well as wildfire victims

Islanders want BC Ferries to follow order that lets residents board before tourists

For ferry-dependent communities, ferries are often the sole practical lifeline to work, school or medical appointments.

Fraser Valley loses the Keith Wilson Waver as Ron Hupper passes away

Hupper brought smiles to the faces of hundreds of people traveling Chilliwack’s Keith Wilson Road

Beverly Hills 90210 star’s family selling Vancouver Island Beach Resort

You can own Jason Priestley’s Terrace Beach Resort in Ucluelet for less than $5 million

Genetic detectives begin work to trace spread of COVID-19 in Canada

The kinds of genetic technology being used for this project did not exist when SARS hit Canada in 2003

Sports fishers protest Fraser River Chinook closures

Public Fishery Alliance wants hatchery fish open for harvest

Woman sexually assaulted, robbed near Surrey SkyTrain station: RCMP

Police say the incident happened July 10, just after 11 p.m. near King George SkyTrain station

B.C. Ferries increasing passenger capacity after COVID-19 restrictions

Transport Canada 50-per-cent limit being phased out, no current plans to provide masks

Four-vehicle collision snarls eastbound highway traffic in Fraser Valley

Collision west of Lickman Road on Highway 1 includes three vehicles plus motorcycle

Most Read