Workers’ cancer cluster claim denied by court

The Court of Appeal is just the latest body to rule on whether or not the women’s employment at the hospital led to the cancer

The B.C. Court of Appeal has upheld a previous court ruling finding no proof for the claim that working at Mission Memorial Hospital’s lab caused breast cancer in former workers.

In the December ruling, the Court of Appeal set aside a previous Workers Compensation Appeal Tribunal decision that had found in favour of Patricia Schmidt, Katrina Hammer and Anne MacFarlane, and agreed with a 2013 Supreme Court decision.

Six lab technicians at the hospital contracted breast cancer between 1970 and 2004 in what was deemed a “cancer cluster.”

The Court of Appeal is just the latest body to rule on whether or not the women’s employment at the hospital led to the cancer.

After the Workers Compensation Board ruled against the women, a Workers’ Compensation Administrative Tribunal (WCAT) disagreed and found in favour of the former MMH employees in 2011.

But the Fraser Health Authority appealed and in 2013, that decision was quashed.

In December, with the case back in court, three of five court of appeal justices again found that the WCAT ruling was “patently unreasonable” and that beyond “an unexplained statistical anomaly” there was no evidence that employment in the lab caused the women to develop breast cancer.

“The suggestion that the cancer was caused by her employment conditions does not rise above speculation,” wrote Justice Richard Goepel.

He agreed with the Supreme Court justice who noted that “a higher-than-expected rate of cancer in a workplace cannot alone provide evidence that the cancer was caused by occupational factors” given a report stating clusters of cancer in a workplace are statistically certain to arise in various places and times.

Two justices dissented, noting that while a court of law would favour a “more technical reading” of expert reports, the WCAT’s decision was not unreasonable and thus should not be before the courts.

Just Posted

Suspects charged after police incident by golf course

Mission and Maple Ridge RCMP combined forces to arrest two men

Mobile complaint clinic coming to Langley Feb. 9

The B.C. Ombudsperson is touring cities, taking complaints against the provincial government

UPDATE: Tsunami warning cancelled for coastal British Columbia

Warning issued following 7.9 earthquake off Kodiak, AK

‘Restless night’ for Semiahmoo First Nation after tsunami warning

Alaska earthquake puts Semiahmoo First Nation on notice

Mission RCMP recover 22 stolen vehicles and several firearms

Charges are still pending after police search two separate properties

Tsunami warnings 101: Canada

Here are some things to know about tsunami alerts in Canada and how they work

Castlegar homicide victim identified

The victim was 38-year-old Jordan Workman of Castlegar, B.C.

B.C. Liberals get one last prime-time pitch

Leadership campaign to be decided in Feb. 3 vote

Homeless evicted from First Nation reserve land say they have nowhere to go

‘Why not just let us stay until spring?’ one camper at Chilliwack site pleads

Andrew Scheer on trade, Trump and Trudeau

Canada’s Conservative leader begins three-day visit to B.C.

Victims restrained, sex toys and cash stolen from B.C. adult store

Armed suspects sought in adult store robbery

UPDATED: 10 Safeways in Lower Mainland to close

Locations in Vancouver, Burnaby, Surrey, Coquitlam, Richmond and Mission slated to shut

Vancouver Islanders ponder need for tsunami siren song

Alarm sounds in Port Alberni but not at the DND base in Esquimalt

Five charged in bid to shut pop-up pot market in Vancouver’s Robson Square

Marijuana flower, edibles, money and some weapons were seized as part of weekend raid

Most Read