Judge throws out gun charges, saying accused’s charter rights were violated

Timothy Ulm was acquitted of all charges in the incident that involved an arrest on the Abbotsford-Mission Highway

A judge has ruled that a man charged in 2014 with several firearms offences experienced a “serious violation” of his charter rights during his arrest, and all charges should be dropped.

The ruling in favour of Timothy Joseph Ulm, 29, was made Oct. 30 in B.C. Supreme Court in Chilliwack following a voir dire (trial within a trial). He had been charged with four firearms-related offences and one count of breaching a court order.

Ulm was arrested on Aug. 24, 2014 following a traffic stop on the Abbotsford-Mission Highway (Highway 11). The court heard that Mission RCMP Const. Powell first spotted Ulm driving on the Lougheed Highway near the Mission-Maple Ridge border at about 12:30 a.m. and noticed a motorcycle, with its lights flashing, strapped onto the bed of Ulm’s truck.

Powell had a hunch that the bike might be stolen – there had been several motorcycle thefts in Mission at the time – and she followed Ulm onto the Mission Bridge, and then pulled him over on Highway 11.

Powell contacted dispatch and discovered that Ulm was serving a non-custodial conditional sentence and was required to have a copy of his order on him. She also learned that one of his conditions prohibited him from possessing firearms.

Ulm did not have a copy of his conditional sentence order (CSO) on him, but Powell was satisfied with his explanation that he thought he had left it behind on Vancouver Island on a trip there, Justice Neill Brown stated in his ruling.

Meanwhile, a second officer, Const. Tilman arrived on the scene for backup. The two officers soon confirmed that the motorcycle was not stolen.

As Powell was speaking with Ulm and informing him that she was going to let him go, Tilman peered inside Ulm’s truck and saw a “butt stock” – the part of a rifle that rests against the shooter’s shoulder when the gun is discharged.

Tilman informed Powell of his discovery, and a more thorough search of the vehicle turned up a 12-gauge shotgun, ammunition for the shotgun and a folding knife. Ulm was arrested on the scene.

Brown ruled that Ulm’s charter rights were violated from the start of the incident, saying that Ulm being detained at the side of the road was “arbitrary.”

“No traffic infraction occurred to justify pulling Mr. Ulm over and detaining him for investigation of the infraction … Const. Powell lacked reasonable grounds to suspect in all circumstances that Mr. Ulm was connected to a particular crime and that his detention was necessary,” the judge stated.

Further, after Powell “unlawfully detained” Ulm, she failed to tell him that she had done so to investigate whether he was transporting a stolen motorcycle and that he was not obliged to answer questions.

The judge also said both officers were negligent when they failed to provide Ulm with charter warnings before searching his truck and when they did not “promptly” advise him of his right to contact a lawyer before the search was conducted.

“I found the officers Charter-infringing conduct serious,” Brown said in throwing out the evidence and acquitting Ulm of all charges after the Crown called no further evidence.

Just Posted

UPDATE: Man, 32, found dead in Abbotsford was targeted, police say

IHIT identifies victim as Sukhpreet Grewal, who they say was known to police

Helping hand for ‘ordinary folks’

Mission’s St. Joseph’s Food Bank caters to regular people facing unforeseen situations

VIDEO: Mission firefighters battle garbage blaze

A 20 foot by 20 foot fire is burning at the Mission landfill

Habitat for Humanity says it owes no money to former CEO

Upper Fraser Valley branch responds to wrongful dismissal lawsuit

No decision on Abbotsford school stabbing suspect’s mental fitness for trial

The BC Review Board could not determine whether Gabriel Klein, 21, is fit to stand trial

BC Games: Day 1 comes to an end

Medals have already been handed out following one day of competition in the 2018 BC Summer Games

BC Wildfire update on Okanagan blazes

Watch the media briefing on the current fire situation in the Okanagan.

RCMP help to save goats from wildfire

The fast-approaching wildfire, sparked Thursday, forced the evacuation of five homes

VIDEO: Near drowning captured on popular B.C. river

Search and Rescue manager says the popular pastime of floating in the summer is inherently dangerous

Crosswalk vandalism leaves black mark for Cowichan as B.C. Games begin

Rainbow crosswalk defaced just days after being painted

Photo gallery: BC Games Day 1

A brief look at action from the 2018 BC Summer Games in the Cowichan Valley

UPDATED: Anti-pipeline campers digging in as eviction deadline expires

The City of Burnaby had ordered the Kinder Morgan pipeline protesters out for violating bylaws

Trump was taped talking of paying Playboy model: AP source

Source says former personal lawyer Michael Cohen secretly recorded discussion prior to 2016 election

BC toddler with ‘allergy’ to sun waiting for bone marrow transplant

Charlie Lock, 2, needs treatment for damage caused by rare disorder EPP

Most Read